Menu of Hurley Bar in Hurley, South Dakota, USA

Menu Overview

Located in the heart of Hurley, South Dakota, Hurley Bar offers a genuine bar and grill experience that resonates with both locals and visitors alike. The menu reflects a blend of traditional bar fare and regional specialties, punctuated by thoughtful homemade options that cater to a variety of palates.

The standout offering here is undoubtedly the Chislic, a beloved South Dakota classic. Served as tender lamb sticks, the Chislic at Hurley Bar is expertly prepared and accompanied by a choice of sauces including Ranch, BBQ, Honey Mustard, Buffalo, Cocktail, and Tartar. Priced at $9 for a half-dozen and $14 for a dozen, it strikes an excellent balance between flavor and value. This dish has won hearty praise from patrons like Don Nelson, who called it "the best in 50 years," underscoring its authentic quality and robust flavor profile.

For those craving something familiar yet satisfying, the bar's homemade pizzas serve as a highlight. Available with thick or thin crust, the large specialty pizza ($16) offers a variety of hearty toppings such as pepperoni, Canadian bacon, Italian sausage, hamburger, and classic vegetables like black olives and green peppers. The single-topping option ($14) is perfect for a more straightforward but equally delicious meal. The crust’s texture and the freshness of toppings reflect the kitchen’s commitment to quality.

Hurley Bar also caters well to its clientele during happy hour, running Monday to Friday from 4 to 7 pm, with discounts on beers and mixed drinks that bring extra value to the social experience. This adds to the welcoming atmosphere documented by many visitors, including Tracy Hummel, who praises the attentive bartenders and excellent food, and Tiffany Thomas, who highlights the clean venue alongside the friendly and kind staff.

While the culinary offerings are impressive, the community spirit and respectful environment at Hurley Bar truly distinguish it. Ulonda Schoolmeester’s note about the non-discriminatory and warm service culture speaks to the inclusive ethos of the establishment. However, it is worth noting that occasional operational quirks occur, such as inconsistent door hours as mentioned by Tessa Daggett—yet they do not significantly detract from the overall experience.

In sum, Hurley Bar’s menu provides hearty, well-executed dishes with an emphasis on local flavor and customer satisfaction. The combination of quality chislic, flavorful pizzas, and a welcoming atmosphere make it a compelling destination for anyone seeking an authentic bar and grill encounter in Hurley, SD.